- Ripple has secured a victory, but its battle with the SEC has not concluded.
- Ripple’s legal team has accused the SEC of an aggressive and unjustified pursuit.
- The SEC’s focus on Ripple has overshadowed its mission to protect investors.
The legal battle between Ripple and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) over XRP may not be over yet. Despite a significant ruling that could redefine the landscape for cryptocurrency regulation, Ripple’s Chief Legal Officer, Stuart Alderoty, anticipates the SEC might still pursue an appeal.
His comments, made during a recent interview, reveal deep skepticism about the SEC’s actions and question the regulator’s rationality in its ongoing approach to crypto-related cases.
Ripple’s CLO Criticizes SEC Strategy
During his interview, Alderoty expressed confidence in the ruling that XRP is not a security, a decision that may set a precedent for how digital assets are treated in the U.S. legal system. However, he also suggested that the SEC, despite clear indications that the case should be closed, might continue to push the matter further.
Sponsored
“If the SEC were a rational actor, they should just move on from this case,” Alderoty stated, pointing out that the court found no victims or losses associated with Ripple’s actions. “There are no allegations of fraud,” he added, highlighting that the case does not align with the SEC’s core mission of protecting investors.
Alderoty was critical of the SEC’s litigation strategy throughout the case, accusing the regulator of “litigation gamesmanship and tactics” rather than a faithful application of the law. His remarks underscore a broader concern within the crypto industry that the SEC has taken an aggressive stance against digital assets, often without clear legal grounds.
Ripple Anticipates an Appeal
Despite the clear victory for Ripple, Alderoty remains cautious. He emphasized that the SEC’s actions in the crypto space have not always been rational, raising the possibility that the regulator might still appeal. “I wouldn’t be surprised if the SEC does appeal,” he remarked, noting the agency’s history of pursuing aggressive legal action in the crypto sector.
Alderoty also reaffirmed that, regardless of an appeal, the current ruling on XRP stands firm. He insisted that “XRP’s status as not a security and the secondary market trading of XRP as not security transactions—that is the law of the land.” According to him, an appeal would not change this legal precedent.
His confidence is bolstered by the statistical reality that appellate courts overturn lower court decisions less than 10% of the time. Throughout the interview, Alderoty repeatedly questioned the SEC’s priorities, suggesting that the regulator is straying from its mission to protect investors.
SEC’s Broader Mission Questioned
Alderoty argued that the SEC should focus on cases where there is actual harm to investors or the market, rather than pursuing what he described as a “baseless” case against Ripple. “This case was an overreach from the outset,” Alderoty said, reflecting on the SEC’s track record in the case.
He urged the regulator to return to its core mission, rather than engaging in what he sees as unnecessary litigation that fails to contribute to the protection of investors. Alderoty’s statements resonate within the broader cryptocurrency community, which has often criticized the SEC for what it perceives as heavy-handed regulation.
On the Flipside
- The SEC’s potential appeal could cast doubt on XRP’s current legal status, unsettling investors and the broader crypto market.
- Ripple’s victory might be temporary if the SEC successfully appeals, potentially leading to a reversal or modification of the ruling.
- An appeal would delay regulatory clarity for XRP, prolonging uncertainty for businesses and users relying on the token.
Why This Matters
The legal conflict highlights critical questions about the consistency and intentions of regulatory enforcement in the crypto industry. It highlights the tension between innovation and regulation, with the outcome potentially redefining how digital assets are treated. The stakes involve both legal precedent and the future direction of crypto regulation.
To dive deeper into why the SEC is favored to win its appeal against Ripple, explore this detailed analysis:
SEC Given 90% Chance to Win Ripple Appeal?! Here’s Why
Curious about Ripple’s XRP and its promising future? Discover more about its potential breakthroughs here:
Ripple’s XRP Sees the Light at the End of the Tunnel
